git404hub

what is dear-github fr?

yyx990803/dear-github — explained in plain English

Analysis updated 2026-07-17 · repo last pushed 2016-01-15

5Audience · developerComplexity · 1/5DormantSetup · easy

tl;dr

An open letter from major open-source maintainers asking GitHub to add issue templates, a voting system, and clearer contributing-guide visibility.

vibe map

mindmap
  root((repo))
    What it does
      Open letter to GitHub
      Signed by maintainers
      Lists frustrations
    Tech stack
      Markdown document
      No code
    Use cases
      Read requests
      Add signature
      Cite in advocacy
    Audience
      Maintainers
      Developers
    Key asks
      Issue templates
      Voting system
      Visible contributing guide

Code map

Detail Auto

An interactive map of this repo's files and how they connect — its source is parsed live in your browser. Click Visualize to build it.

filefunction / class

what do people make with this?

VIBE 1

Read the collective feature requests open-source maintainers have for GitHub.

VIBE 2

Add your project's name as a signer to show support for the requests.

VIBE 3

Reference it when advocating for better issue-tracking tools on GitHub.

VIBE 4

Understand common maintainer pain points before building your own repo-management tool.

how it stacks up fr

yyx990803/dear-github00kaku/wp-rest-playground1ncendium/aibuster
Stars555
LanguageJavaScriptPython
Last pushed2016-01-15
MaintenanceDormant
Setup difficultyeasyhardmoderate
Complexity1/53/53/5
Audiencedeveloperdeveloperops devops

Figures from each repo's GitHub metadata at analysis time.

how do i run it?

Difficulty · easy time til it works · 5min

in plain english

This repository is an open letter to GitHub from the people who maintain some of the world's most popular open source projects, like React, jQuery, TypeScript, and Babel. These maintainers are frustrated because they feel ignored by GitHub when they ask for features or report problems. The core complaint is that GitHub has become essential infrastructure for open source development, yet there's no real way for project maintainers to get help or know what GitHub is working on. When they submit requests through GitHub's support channels, they either get no response or an empty one, with no visibility into whether their feedback matters or will ever be addressed. For projects that operate transparently and accept community input, this lack of communication feels especially strange. The letter outlines three specific problems the signers want GitHub to fix. First, issues often lack important details like how to reproduce a bug or which version was tested, and they want GitHub to support custom fields and issue templates to ensure people provide this information upfront. Second, issues get flooded with low-value "+1" comments that don't add anything but clutter the conversation, they'd like a proper voting system instead so maintainers can see interest without the spam. Third, new contributors often ignore contribution guidelines because they're hard to find and buried alongside irrelevant information, so maintainers want the ability to display a simple, customizable file front-and-center on the issue creation page. The letter's tone is respectful but pointed: these requests aren't new, and the signers have been waiting years for progress. They note the irony that if GitHub itself were open source, they'd implement these features themselves, that's what they're good at. The letter is signed by dozens of major project maintainers and invites others to add their names, making a collective case that GitHub's tools need to evolve alongside the community it hosts.

prompts (copy fr)

prompt 1
Summarize the three main feature requests in this open letter to GitHub.
prompt 2
Draft a similar open letter for a different platform based on this format.
prompt 3
Explain why maintainers want a voting system instead of +1 comments.
prompt 4
List alternative tools that already solve the problems this letter describes.

Frequently asked questions

what is dear-github fr?

An open letter from major open-source maintainers asking GitHub to add issue templates, a voting system, and clearer contributing-guide visibility.

Is dear-github actively maintained?

Dormant — no commits in 2+ years (last push 2016-01-15).

How hard is dear-github to set up?

Setup difficulty is rated easy, with roughly 5min to a first successful run.

Who is dear-github for?

Mainly developer.

peek the repo → explain another one

This repo across BitVibe Labs

double-check against the repo, no cap.